will england :: motorcycle notes and tips

HID Light questions and answers


The lifetime of the bulb is inversely proportional to the number on and off
cycles, but that number is quite high.  Even so, a new bulb is about US$100,
and even with frequent on:off cycling, will last at least about 3000 to 4000
operating hours, which would mean many, many years of riding for most
riders, and many times longer than most high performance 'crotch rocket'
bikes will last.   Therefore, to answer your question directly:  Don't worry
about such cycling as necessary for on coming traffic.

The Hella Luminator (HID or Halogen) is, of course, much superior for its
light output, but because it is such an extremely robust light, it is heavy
(about 3 kg each, I believe), and about 9 inches in diameter.  This light
would only be useful on a motorcycle if mounted very low on very sturdy
crashbars, and one then has to note that a fall could likely damage the
lights.  These lights are capable of being mounted in virtually any
position, vertical, pendant, or horizontally.

The much lighter weight FF1000 HID has a diameter of about 7 inches, puts
out lots of usable light, but has the distinct disadvantage of only being
mountable in the upright, vertical position, not in the pendant position -
although several friends have done so (mounted them in pendant position) and
have had no problems in over 50,000 miles, including god-awfully rough trips
through Mexico's Copper Canyon and lots of rough, washboard and worse
off-road trips.  Still, I will stay with the restrictions provided by
Hella's engineers.

The Hella Micro Xenon HID's are very light weight, compact, and put out an
amazing amount of light - lots more than it appears in the Hella comparison
chart.  They are also very easy to protect in the event of a fall because of
their compact size.   Still, the laws of physics are immutable:  bigger
reflectors are better.  No amount of "cutsy", "artsy" or other marketing
crap can allow small reflector lights to be anything more than a fashion
statement.  Religious fervor and loud arguments in a rationalization to
defend small or non-round "artsy" designs will overcome the real life laws
of physics.  The only known light that is of rectangular design that puts
out a highly efficient amount of light for its size is the Hella Micro
Xenon, but that is due to an extremely sophisticated but simple appearing
bulb orientation and reflector design.  Otherwise, stay very strictly with
round only reflectors.

Where space and weight is a dominant consideration, the Micro Xenon are
likely the best choice, despite the clearly substantial loss in light
output.  These lights can be mounted vertically or in pendant (upside down)
position.

Where a bit more space is available, the Comet 200 HID lights are the next
best choice, having a round design and larger reflector.  They also can be
mounted in vertical or pendant position.

If still more space is available, light weight is a serious consideration,
and you can live with the upright-only vertical position mounting
limitation, then the Hella FF1000 HID lights are frankly impossible to beat,
and my personal recommendation as the optimal compromise for motorcycle use,
where weight is always a major consideration.  Another thing of great
importance to those doing extensive traveling, especially where gravel or
other non-perfect roads are encountered, is that the Hella FF1000 HID is the
only light with an extremely robust Lexan lens, making it virtually
impossible to break even by impacts with substantial, fast moving rocks.

The Hella 2100 HID uses an older design reflector technology, so is less
efficient for its size than others, and suffers further because of its
non-round, rectangular design.  However, when mounted low as a fog and
broadly scattering light when aimed in an X pattern, at an angle for side
illumination while steeply leaned over in tight turns, these lights are
great, and the scattering losses of the prismatic lenses for coherency over
distance is an important asset during such use, as in mountain twisties.

Obviously, nothing else comes close to the Hella Luminator (AKA  "Predator"
in Australia, New Zealand and Asia).  They are incredibly rugged, but at 3
kg each, seem to me to be too heavy for motorcycle use.   Please, seriously
investigate your possible mounting positions such that the light is
reasonably well protected from breakage during a fall.  All manner of
protective devices and other light shields and accessories are available for
this light.  Mounted low, on a very sturdy mount, and where the weight is
not so important, these are fabulous lights, and will last lifetimes and
still be as good as new.

Conversion kits for the stock headlights are readily available from Philips.
Some of these kits also use the same D2S bulb as does Hella, but some use
the 20% less efficient D2R light bulb.  Either is a vast improvement over
the stock headlights, and they are never likely to fail throughout the
entire lifetime of most bikes, or even several bikes.  Just changing the
bulb starts everything to the "as new" situation, and they use far less
power.  They are vastly better than any Halogen light ever possibly could be
in all respects except initial cost.

As in all things, different uses require different optimizations.  Like
everything in real life, everything is simple when one knows nothing about
the subject (ignorant of the many important factors beyond one's current
awareness).   It is when one begins to become aware of the many factors
involved that things get more difficult, because of such awareness.  Still,
ignorance is never bliss.  On motorcycles, or when flying airplanes, or
other critical situations, ignorance greatly enhances one's chances of
realizing serious problems.   Awareness greatly reduces such problems to
quite acceptable levels.  Make your choices wisely, take your time, but
PLEASE stay with the HID lights everywhere possible.   I cannot begin to
emphasize what a fantastic improvement they make in your safety, and
(importantly to me) in the safety of the many animals though whose homes we
pass.

Colonel
'00 BMW R1150GS
'94 BMW R1100RS
Silly Valley, CA



Return to index

note: this article is by the listed author. all articles have been collected from various usenet groups and e-mail lists. DMCA violations, errors, omissions, complaints to will england. compliments to listed author. if no author is listed, none was provided in the source material. all information is correct to the best of my knowledge; however it has not been independently verified. use at your own risk; this database of information is for entertainment purposes only. no warranty is given or implied.